Switzerland: Federal Court condemns Dublin detention of family

Swiss Federal Court

The Swiss Federal Court delivered a ruling on 16 May 2017 finding that an Afghan family had been unlawfully detained pending a transfer to Norway under the Dublin Regulation.

In October 2016, the authorities of the Zug canton transported the family to the airport with a view to effecting the transfer to Norway. The family refused to board the plane, fearing that they would be returned to Afghanistan from Norway. Following their refusal, they were separated for a period of three weeks, as the parents were detained together with their four-month-old baby while the other two children were placed in a separate centre. The Federal Court found the detention to be unlawful and contrary to the right to family life, given that the Zug authorities had not examined less coercive alternatives prior to ordering detention.

The detention of families is not a rare practice in Switzerland, although authorities usually detain the father while placing the mother and children in a reception centre. In rare cases it happens that a single parent or both parents are detained.

The issue of Dublin transfers of Afghan asylum seekers to Norway has been the subject of debate in other countries as well. In France, the Administrative Court of Lyon recently suspended the Dublin transfer of an Afghan national to Norway, on the ground that his asylum application had been rejected in Norway and that he would run a risk of refoulement to Afghanistan.


For more information, see:

About AIDA

The Asylum Information Database (AIDA) is a database managed by the European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE), containing information on asylum procedures, reception conditions, detenti