Alternatives to detention are permitted by legislation but not required. Permitted are:
Guidelines say that detention should only be used as a last resort. However, no proof is required that alternatives are not effective. Residence restrictions and regular reporting are routinely applied to all asylum seekers, and bail will always include residence restrictions and reporting. Breach of these conditions may result in detention. Electronic tagging is in frequent use mainly for ex-offenders and may be a bail condition. Numbers of asylum seekers tagged are not available. New guidance relating to Immigration Bail was issued in August 2018. This guidance includes the process for referring detainees for automatic bail consideration, in most cases, four months after the person was first detained and every four months thereafter.
In September 2016, Detention Action published a report on community-based alternatives to detention, exploring their potential use in the immigration control context and calling for their further development. The Detention Forum has produced a guide to alternatives to detention.
In response to the second report by Stephen Shaw on the detention of vulnerable people, the government announced that some specific projects (alternatives) would be developed in partnership with the voluntary sector. Details of the first of these was announced in December 2018. UNHCR is evaluating the pilots and published the first one in January 2022, looking at a project to avoid detaining women.
An inquiry by the parliamentary Joint Committee on Human Rights published evidence as it was submitted (oral and written), including evidence from the government. In evidence to the Committee the Immigration Minister stated that in the 10 months since the automatic bail policy was introduced 10% of automatic bail hearings have resulted in the detainee being granted bail.
The Committee published its report on 7 February 2019 and made five main recommendations:
- The decision to detain should not be made by the Home Office but should be made independently.
- Introduce a 28-day time limit to end the trauma of indefinite detention.
- Detainees should have better and more consistent access to legal aid to challenge their detention.
- More needs to be done to identify vulnerable individuals and treat them appropriately.
- The Home Office should improve the oversight and assurance mechanism in the immigration detention estate to ensure that any ill-treatment of abuse is found out immediately and action is taken. Concerns over the distressing effect of indeterminate detention.
The government responded in July 2019. The response highlighted progress in the areas of transparency of data, vulnerable people in detention and the introduction of a two-month auto referral for bail in February 2019. In 2021 the All Party Parliamentary Group on Detention published a report into ‘quasi detention which included those held in an Immigration Removal Centre as well as the former military barracks.
 Section 36 AITOCA.
 Para 21(2) Schedule 2 Immigration Act 1971.
 Section 61 Schedule 10 Immigration Act 2016.
 Para 21(2) Schedule 2 Immigration Act 1971.
 Home Office, Immigration bail, August 2018, available at: https://bit.ly/2xxta19.
 Detention Action, Without detention: Opportunities for alternatives, September 2016, available at: http://bit.ly/2kS7qoR.
 Detention Forum, Alternatives to detention: Frequently asked questions, July 2018, available at https://bit.ly/2pDYpmF.
 Stephen Shaw, Welfare in detention of vulnerable people review: progress report, July 2018, available at: https://bit.ly/2JQVvmb.
 Home Office, ‘Home Secretary statement on immigration detention and Shaw report’, 24 July 2018, available at: https://bit.ly/2uVZdGQ.
 Home Office, ‘New pilot schemes to support migrants at risk of detention’, 3 December 2018, available at: https://bit.ly/2QQEj3X.
 UNHCR, Terms of reference: Evaluation of UK Home Office Alternatives to Detention Community Engagement Pilot Series, October 2019, available at: https://bit.ly/36Dtvhp.
 Evaluation of ‘Action Access’; an alternatives to detention pilot, UNHCR 2022 https://bit.ly/3BEmfDb
 Minister of State for Immigration, ‘Use of immigration detention: The Government’s strategic approach’, 3 December 2018, available at: https://bit.ly/2DdzNc0.
 Joint Committee on Human Rights, Oral evidence session, HC 1484, 5 December 2018, available at: https://bit.ly/2TjsfON.
 Joint Committee on Human Rights, Immigration Detention Inquiry, 7 February 2019, available at: https://bit.ly/2HVfZyF.
 Letter from the Minister of state for Immigration to the chair of the Joint Committee on Human Rights, 23 July 2019, available at: https://bit.ly/2O7PA1a.
 APPG Detention https://bit.ly/33E4F5E.